Is Content Validity Valid?

"The belief in reality is essentially the conviction that an entity transcends immediate sense data; or, to put the same point more plainly, it is the conviction that what is real but hidden has more content than what is given and obvious." (Bachelard, 1984, p. 31-32)

"It is in the determination of invariants that the mathematization of the real finds its true justification" (p. 36). "The whole problem of scientific knowledge of the real turns on the initial choice of mathematics. When one has fully comprehended... that experimentation is always dependent on some prior intellectual construct, then it is obvious why one should look to the abstract for proof of the coherence of the concrete. Empirical possibilities are in one-to-one correspondence with sets of axioms" (p. 41).

The conventional focus on content validity has misled us about what is important in educational measurement. As Bachelard puts it, the abstract has more content than the given and obvious. But content validity enforces conformity to that selfsame given and obvious.

Perhaps the issue of validity is a political one. Teachers often say that they don't want to teach, but to creatively engage in learning with their students. Testing practice, of course, subverts such idealism:

"the method of scaling an educational achievement test should not be permitted to determine the content of the test." (E.F. Lindquist, 1953, p.35)

"above all else, a criterion-referenced test must have content validity" (Hambleton & Novick, 1973, p. 168).

"no recourse to response-inferred concepts" can be allowed in assessing test validity. (Osburn, 1968, p. 101)

Education in practice is a rigid hierarchy of authority in which objectives determine curriculum and curriculum determines test content. Since students are allowed no voice in test content, educational achievement is measured via a one-sided monologue, if not harangue, in which the system, represented by the teacher, does all the talking. In effect, then, educational achievement occurs in a public way only to the extent that students conform to criteria that are politically determined outside of the classroom by people not directly involved in the teaching process.

Rasch measurement has the audacity to regard the students' responses (not the statements of the authority figures) to be the empirical realization of the abstract. It includes the students as participants in a dialogue in which the object is to explore, elaborate, and, if possible, reveal the hidden and abstract construct to be measured. Of course, that dialogue can remove barriers to human contact, requiring sensitivity, attention, and judgment. Many in education may not want that. Allowing statistical inconsistencies in the data to suggest that some test questions may be irrelevant to the conversation at hand, poorly phrased, ambiguous, or easily misunderstood could lead to changes in the curriculum and in the overall objectives. But these changes may address issues that the educational system would rather ignore.

If we are truly concerned to investigate the real (but abstract) rather than the ephemeral (but concrete), then Lindquist must be turned on his head: The content of an educational achievement test must not be permitted to determine the method of scaling.

William P. Fisher, Jr.

Bachelard, Gaston (1984) The New Scientific Spirit. Beacon Press.

Lindquist E. F. (1953) Selecting appropriate score scales for tests (Discussion). Proceedings of the 1952 Invitational Conference on Testing Problems. Princeton NJ: Educational Testing Service

Hambleton R. K., Novick M. R. (1973) Toward an integration of theory and method for criterion-referenced tests. Journal of Educational Measurement, 10, 159-170.

Osburn H. G. (1968) Item sampling for achievement testing. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 28, 95-104.


Is Content Validity Valid? Fisher W. P. Jr. … Rasch Measurement Transactions, 1997, 11:1 p. 548.



Rasch-Related Resources: Rasch Measurement YouTube Channel
Rasch Measurement Transactions & Rasch Measurement research papers - free An Introduction to the Rasch Model with Examples in R (eRm, etc.), Debelak, Strobl, Zeigenfuse Rasch Measurement Theory Analysis in R, Wind, Hua Applying the Rasch Model in Social Sciences Using R, Lamprianou El modelo métrico de Rasch: Fundamentación, implementación e interpretación de la medida en ciencias sociales (Spanish Edition), Manuel González-Montesinos M.
Rasch Models: Foundations, Recent Developments, and Applications, Fischer & Molenaar Probabilistic Models for Some Intelligence and Attainment Tests, Georg Rasch Rasch Models for Measurement, David Andrich Constructing Measures, Mark Wilson Best Test Design - free, Wright & Stone
Rating Scale Analysis - free, Wright & Masters
Virtual Standard Setting: Setting Cut Scores, Charalambos Kollias Diseño de Mejores Pruebas - free, Spanish Best Test Design A Course in Rasch Measurement Theory, Andrich, Marais Rasch Models in Health, Christensen, Kreiner, Mesba Multivariate and Mixture Distribution Rasch Models, von Davier, Carstensen
Rasch Books and Publications: Winsteps and Facets
Applying the Rasch Model (Winsteps, Facets) 4th Ed., Bond, Yan, Heene Advances in Rasch Analyses in the Human Sciences (Winsteps, Facets) 1st Ed., Boone, Staver Advances in Applications of Rasch Measurement in Science Education, X. Liu & W. J. Boone Rasch Analysis in the Human Sciences (Winsteps) Boone, Staver, Yale Appliquer le modèle de Rasch: Défis et pistes de solution (Winsteps) E. Dionne, S. Béland
Introduction to Many-Facet Rasch Measurement (Facets), Thomas Eckes Rasch Models for Solving Measurement Problems (Facets), George Engelhard, Jr. & Jue Wang Statistical Analyses for Language Testers (Facets), Rita Green Invariant Measurement with Raters and Rating Scales: Rasch Models for Rater-Mediated Assessments (Facets), George Engelhard, Jr. & Stefanie Wind Aplicação do Modelo de Rasch (Português), de Bond, Trevor G., Fox, Christine M
Exploring Rating Scale Functioning for Survey Research (R, Facets), Stefanie Wind Rasch Measurement: Applications, Khine Winsteps Tutorials - free
Facets Tutorials - free
Many-Facet Rasch Measurement (Facets) - free, J.M. Linacre Fairness, Justice and Language Assessment (Winsteps, Facets), McNamara, Knoch, Fan

To be emailed about new material on www.rasch.org
please enter your email address here:

I want to Subscribe: & click below
I want to Unsubscribe: & click below

Please set your SPAM filter to accept emails from Rasch.org

www.rasch.org welcomes your comments:

Your email address (if you want us to reply):

 

ForumRasch Measurement Forum to discuss any Rasch-related topic

Go to Top of Page
Go to index of all Rasch Measurement Transactions
AERA members: Join the Rasch Measurement SIG and receive the printed version of RMT
Some back issues of RMT are available as bound volumes
Subscribe to Journal of Applied Measurement

Go to Institute for Objective Measurement Home Page. The Rasch Measurement SIG (AERA) thanks the Institute for Objective Measurement for inviting the publication of Rasch Measurement Transactions on the Institute's website, www.rasch.org.

Coming Rasch-related Events
Oct. 4 - Nov. 8, 2024, Fri.-Fri. On-line workshop: Rasch Measurement - Core Topics (E. Smith, Winsteps), www.statistics.com
Jan. 17 - Feb. 21, 2025, Fri.-Fri. On-line workshop: Rasch Measurement - Core Topics (E. Smith, Winsteps), www.statistics.com
May 16 - June 20, 2025, Fri.-Fri. On-line workshop: Rasch Measurement - Core Topics (E. Smith, Winsteps), www.statistics.com
June 20 - July 18, 2025, Fri.-Fri. On-line workshop: Rasch Measurement - Further Topics (E. Smith, Facets), www.statistics.com
Oct. 3 - Nov. 7, 2025, Fri.-Fri. On-line workshop: Rasch Measurement - Core Topics (E. Smith, Winsteps), www.statistics.com

 

The URL of this page is www.rasch.org/rmt/rmt111j.htm

Website: www.rasch.org/rmt/contents.htm